Cleo cherishes his position as a youth pastor in the suburbs of Denver, but his sincere support for a teenage girl has put his career at risk. When the church’s Elder Board learns of the situation, they request that he take a two-week leave to reflect on his actions and their implications for his ministry. Upset by receiving this news through an email, Cleo decides to pack a backpack, hop on his bike, and embark on a journey to discover the truth. His path leads him toward Edmond, Oklahoma, after he gets a lift from a mysterious traveler named Larry, who is accompanied by his deceased father. Larry’s deep skepticism, along with a series of strange signs, prompts Cleo to question not only his connection with the teenager but also the very essence of Love itself.