Maggie and Jack, who have been friends since childhood, now co-host a popular local radio show where they offer dating advice. When they learn that their show might be picked up for national syndication, their boss suggests they introduce their partners to their families during a live New Year’s Eve broadcast. With their fathers’ jazz club, The Magnolia, facing financial difficulties, Maggie and Jack agree to the special, provided it takes place at the club. However, when both are unexpectedly dumped before the event, Jack proposes they fake a romantic relationship and surprise their audience with a midnight kiss on New Year’s Eve.