Aspiring journalist Allie Rusch is enlisted by the spiteful music manager Vivian Cartwright to act as a matchmaker for renowned pop stars Caleb Greene and Carson Peet, with the promise of an exclusive story during Valentine’s weekend. However, Allie quickly discovers that Caleb is more interested in her than in Carson. Caught between a significant career opportunity and her developing emotions for Caleb, Allie must decide whether to push Caleb into a relationship he doesn’t want or to embrace her feelings and make him her Valentine.