In this comedic film, Jennifer Carpenter, Kristen Connolly, and Alexander Poe portray three New Yorkers navigating the complexities of their love lives. After his most recent romantic disaster, Graham (played by Poe) tries to reignite the flame with his former girlfriend, Laura (Connolly). However, as he endeavors to win her back, Graham stumbles upon an unusual predicament: both Laura and another of his ex-girlfriends (Carpenter) are involved with the same man.