Emily has been managing the family dairy farm since her father’s death, but it’s now facing financial difficulties. Her sister, Dorothy, arrives with Charlie, her attractive business associate, suggesting they sell the farm. Determined to keep it, Emily devises a clever strategy to purchase her sister’s shares. She launches an online contest for holiday ice cream flavors, which gains massive popularity thanks to a special ingredient—Charlie’s delicious apple pie. However, as the deadline on Christmas Eve for the buyout looms, Emily finds herself in need of a Christmas miracle to preserve the farm and honor her father’s legacy.