Teen sweethearts Annie and Ben, eager to escape their small town, decide to run away together. However, their dreams of city life are dashed when Annie’s parents annul their marriage. Ben relocates to New York, while Annie remains in Iowa to support her family. Fast forward fifteen years, both are now engaged to other people when they learn that their annulment was never completed. As they meet to finalize their divorce, they find themselves reflecting on their past and the possibilities it held. With old feelings rekindling, Annie and Ben face the dilemma of whether their youthful romance might still hold the promise of a future together.