High school sweethearts Grace (Rena Sofer) and Michael (Dean McDermott) cross paths again at their school reunion after two decades. As they reconnect, old feelings resurface, but complications arise since Grace is currently with the dependable Philip and is committed to making the right choice. Adding to the complexity is Grace’s well-intentioned yet intrusive mother, Mary (Barbara Eden), who also thinks her daughter should stay with Philip. Will genuine love prevail, or will their opportunity for a second chance be extinguished?