Holiday enthusiast Addie (Cindy Sampson) makes a Christmas wish for her neighbor Sam (Robin Dunne) to fall in love with her, not anticipating any real outcome. However, things take an unexpected turn when the wish backfires, causing her other neighbor, Pete (Chris Violette), to fall for her instead. As Pete’s romantic overtures become increasingly extravagant, Addie enlists Sam’s help. With Sam by her side, can Addie undo the spell before Christmas arrives, or is she destined to spend her life with a smitten Pete?