Born on September 11, 2001, Danny seems to be marked by misfortune. His challenging home environment and social struggles result in a solitary childhood. However, during high school, he finds his niche by joining a church youth group. Things start to look up until he develops an unreciprocated crush on his stunning classmate Megan, who has no interest in church-going boys. While participating in his church’s drama team, Danny uncovers a knack for creating new personas. An unexpected encounter in costume makes him realize that Megan is drawn to him when she believes he’s a rebel. Embracing this new identity, Danny partners with Megan to help her get back at her terrible ex-boyfriend. Will this charade work, or is Danny headed for another calamity?